Was on sale, so I picked it up. I had played the other two in the series reboot, and rather liked the spoke/hub model on discovery/tombs. Storyline… the series has way more in common with Assassin Creed’s “nebulous bad guy” motif than much else.
SotTB (huh) seems to have taken a turn from the previous “world first” model to “story first”. There’s 1 main hub, then a smattering of other smaller locations that are attached. Pretty much everything is accessible from the first pass through, which I guess is an improvement. I personally enjoyed the backtracking in the other games, as it provided a sense of player progression. Here, the skills/items you get within 10 minutes are the same used all the way to the end. Which is fine I guess – it works for Uncharted.
The storyline here is a fair bit darker, with Lara having to face her own internal demons. She’s clearly obsessed with exploration to fill in a gap. And while the whole world is at stake with an apocalypse (that she triggers), apparently there’s time to find stolen dice from a child. I don’t quite get it. I do think this is the best villain the series has had in a long time. You get a much better appreciation for his motivations than expected. His 2nd in command doesn’t get that treatment.
Combat has been dramatically reduced in volume. Fact, you barely have any of it until the last 20 minutes. This split means that combat is more difficult, because you’re never really prepared for it and forget some bits. The madness arrow in particular is only shown in the final bit, yet acts like a “god weapon”. I can still remember fights in the 2nd game where I would need to restart a half dozen times due to shielded enemies throwing grenades. None of that here. Fact, the last zone I just rushed through with the assault rifle on full blast and ignored all the other mechanics.
Bows are so done. I still think they are an amazing weapon, but here they are neutered by everyone having a helmet and not being open to a single shot kill. Instead, the shotgun is king… which really doesn’t have a Tomb Raider fell, right? I miss the more strategic planning for combat.
The world is very linear, but the puzzles therein are really quite good. The mirror tomb made me put down the controller to really think about it. The galleon puzzle looked amazing. They are real highlights. The rewards for each are additional skill benefits, which while cool, you rarely notice it. Swimming faster… ok. That said, the world looks amazing. The world designers should get some serious kudos!
The whole package comes out weaker than the previous two. There are certainly higher highs here, but the lows bring it down. Playing it again, I would drop the combat difficulty to super easy mode so that the focus can be instead placed on exploration/story. If you can pick it up with all the DLC (tombs) attached, then that would be a really good deal.